Pet Parents Are Saving Big With These Pet Isnurance Tricks

Did you know simple policy tweaks and overlooked discounts could cut your pet insurance bill significantly in 2025? Discover proven ways to customize coverage, stack savings, and keep your pet protected—without overpaying for extras you don’t need.

Choosing the Most Suitable Plan Type

Accident-Only vs. Accident & Illness Coverage

The initial decision involves selecting between accident-only and comprehensive accident & illness plans. Accident-only policies are generally less expensive (averaging $17/month for dogs, $9.68/month for cats as of 2025), and may be appropriate for healthy or older pets primarily needing coverage for emergency, accident-related care. For those concerned mainly about sudden injuries or with pets that reach certain age limits for illness coverage (some insurers apply illness coverage limits after age 9), accident-only coverage may provide essential benefits at a lower cost (Bankrate, Money, CNBC).

Comprehensive (accident & illness) plans offer broader covered services, including diagnostic tests, medications, hospitalizations, and chronic conditions, but usually result in higher premiums. Evaluate your pet’s age, breed risks, and your own budget to determine which plan best fits your needs.

Adjusting Your Policy to Manage Costs

Pet insurance policies typically allow you to adjust several areas that affect monthly pricing:

Reimbursement Rate: Selecting a lower reimbursement rate (such as 70% rather than 90% or 100%) typically reduces premiums, though you’ll pay more out of pocket for claims.
Annual Deductible: Increasing your deductible generally decreases your monthly premium, with higher deductible amounts resulting in higher up-front costs before coverage begins.
Coverage Limits: Choosing annual payout limits, such as a $5,000 cap rather than unlimited coverage, can lower your premium if you are able to cover part of larger expenses yourself.
Add-Ons: Opting out of wellness or dental riders may be cost-effective if annual preventive care costs are less than what you would pay in higher premiums.
Changes As Your Pet Ages: If your pet moves to limited coverage (often after age 9 for illness coverage), consider accident-only policies or raising your deductible.

Providers usually allow you to customize these variables during enrollment or renewal, and online quote tools can help you compare outcomes for each option (Bankrate, Money).

Comparing Multiple Insurer Quotes

Premiums for similar coverage can vary between insurance providers. For instance, in 2025, monthly premiums for a 1-year-old dog might range from $40 to over $100, depending on the provider and chosen options (Money). Comparison websites, such as Pawlicy Advisor or Pet Insurer, can help you efficiently review available offers. It is advisable to check rates annually to see if a different provider may offer a better fit for your needs.

Exploring Discount Opportunities

Many insurers offer discounts that may be combined in some cases:

Multi-Pet Enrollments: Enrolling more than one pet can qualify you for 5–10% savings per pet.
Professional and Group Discounts: Certain employee groups, such as military personnel or healthcare workers, and members of specific organizations (e.g., Costco offering 15% off with Figo), may be eligible for special pricing.
Annual Payments: Paying premiums annually, when available, may reduce costs by up to 5%.
Bundled Coverage Discount: Some insurers offer a discount (e.g., 10% off with Lemonade) when you purchase multiple types of insurance from the same provider.
Adoption Discounts: Partner shelters or rescues may provide trial periods or exclusive discounts for adopters.
Claim-Free Rewards: Some providers (such as Figo and MetLife) reduce your deductible for each year a claim is not filed.

Requesting a full list of available discounts from each provider is recommended, as stacking them may further reduce your costs (CNBC, Money).

The Advantages of Early Enrollment

It is generally less expensive to insure pets at a younger age, with lower premiums and fewer exclusions for pre-existing conditions. As pets age, premiums typically rise—sometimes by up to 20–30% annually—so enrolling sooner can help you secure more favorable terms (Bankrate, Money, CNBC).

Periodically Reviewing Coverage

Veterinary care costs and related insurance premiums have increased in 2025, sometimes by 20–30% annually. At renewal time, it’s prudent to:

Compare your current policy against new offerings on the market.
Adjust policy features such as deductible, reimbursement rate, or coverage limits to better match your budget.
Remove add-ons that no longer offer value (for example, routine wellness if its out-of-pocket cost is lower than the premium increase).
Consider new discounts or switching providers for a better deal.

Regular reviews are especially important as your pet’s health and coverage needs may change over time (Money).

Consulting Your Veterinarian

Veterinarians can provide informed guidance by:

Identifying breed- or age-specific risks so you select the most relevant coverage.
Providing recommendations regarding insurer reputations for claims processing.

Consulting your veterinarian may help you avoid unnecessary coverage and ensure a smoother claims experience (Bankrate).

Considering Wellness Add-Ons

Wellness and routine care options are available as add-ons. If your annual routine veterinary costs (such as vaccines and check-ups) are lower than the added premium, it may be more economical to pay those costs directly, unless your pet is likely to require frequent preventive care (CNBC, Money). For younger animals or those with known ongoing needs, wellness plans might still provide value.

Eligibility and Enrollment Information for 2025

Age Limits: Most insurers allow enrollment starting at 7–8 weeks of age; coverage for illness may not be available for new enrollees older than 9, at which point accident-only policies may be offered.
Pre-Existing Conditions: Most providers exclude pre-existing or chronic illnesses identified before or during initial waiting periods, though a few (e.g., AKC) may consider coverage after a year of continuous enrollment.
Waiting Periods: Standard waiting periods range from 1–14 days for accidents and up to 14 days for illnesses. Certain conditions, like orthopedic issues, often require longer waits.

Review these criteria during the quote and sign-up process to ensure you select an appropriate plan and can take advantage of available discounts.

Conclusion

Pet insurance in 2025 remains a manageable expense for many US pet owners. Consider tailoring coverage types, adjusting policy features, utilizing discounts, enrolling pets early, regularly reviewing the plan, carefully adding or omitting wellness coverage, consulting your veterinarian, and comparing providers to make informed financial decisions and meet the healthcare needs of your pet.

Sources

Disclaimer: All content, including text, graphics, images and information, contained on or available through this web site is for general information purposes only. The information and materials contained in these pages and the terms, conditions and descriptions that appear, are subject to change without notice.

Lifestyle